vampirefrog wrote:
How will we deal with user logins?
Perhaps it is better to manually transfer the posts, and have users register/login only if they want to.
That sounds like a huge amount of work I really don't want to burden you with, but if you have a plan on how to easily deal with it then, by all means, I'm 100% for it.
When I transferred the old forums of my own project to the current myBB I just orphaned all the users and asked them to recreate an account, if they wanted to keep posting, and I just emptied their passwords so that they couldn't log on anymore.
There could also be overlap between users on P2612 which are registered on vgmrips as well, leading to name collisions which could create confusion between "imported" P2612 users and current vgmrips users.
Back then I solved this issue by appending "_imported" to all the user names and giving them a special role.
A possible solution to this would be akin to what I did:
1. Export the P2612 database to recreate the forum structure of P2612 with all the sections and posts to a file
2. Clear all the passwords so that the users can no longer log in (and emails as well, so that there is no way to reset the passwords and have a new one)
3. Append something like "_P2612" to all user names
4. Re-enumerate the users' IDs so that they don't collide with the ones on vgmrips (I didn't have to do this because the new forums were empty)
5. Alter the tables so that they can be cleanly imported on vgmrips, ending up in a dedicated read-only section
But I have no idea how phpBB works and if it has some clever way to import other forums into a subsection. All of the above were the steps I went through doing some massive SQL queries (and failing several times before getting it right) in order to import all the data from my old forum to the new one.